%2Ffit-in%2F250x250%2Fguide_websites%2F15216%2Fimages%2F1714715167779logo.png&w=1920&q=100)
California & Southern Flounder Caught in NYC Waters
Flounder Fishing in New York City - What to Expect
%2F%2Fusers%2F25978da6-7973-4844-932c-2810a694f178%2Fimages%2Fnyc-flounder-fishing-catch-2791.jpg&w=1920&q=75)
Fishing Charter by Captain Jared Weigel in July
Meet your Captain Jared Weigel
- Embark on Fishing Charters in New York City!
Summary
On a July fishing charter in New York City, Captain Jared Weigel of J Rod3 Charters guided anglers to productive flounder grounds, where both California flounder and Southern flounder proved abundant. This fishing charter delivered memorable catches while showcasing the diverse marine life thriving in NYC waters.
Fishing Charter with Captain Jared Weigel - Rates & Booking
Captain Jared Weigel of J Rod3 Charters led an afternoon fishing charter on Friday, July 24th that proved exactly what New York City anglers have been waiting for. The day on the water centered around targeting flounder in productive local grounds, and the results spoke for themselves.
With J Rod3 Charters, you're getting a guide with genuine local knowledge of NYC's fishing opportunities. Captain Weigel understands the seasonal patterns, the best tidal windows, and exactly where flounder congregate throughout the year. His experience navigating these waters means your fishing time stays productive rather than spent searching. To book your own flounder fishing charter or learn about current rates and available dates, contact J Rod3 Charters directly to reserve your spot on the water.
Highlights of This Fishing Charter
Landing both California flounder and Southern flounder in a single outing is a solid day for any angler. These species represent what makes NYC waters special - you're not locked into targeting just one type of fish. The variety keeps the experience dynamic and gives anglers the chance to learn different techniques and presentations throughout the day.
The charter also showcased the unique positioning of New York City fishing. Urban waterways often get overlooked, but the ecosystem here supports healthy populations of quality fish. A good captain knows how to tap into these opportunities, and that's exactly what happened during this charter.
Local Species Insights: California & Southern Flounder
California flounder and Southern flounder are both bottom-dwellers that thrive in the coastal waters surrounding New York City. These fish share similar behaviors - they're ambush predators that settle on sandy or silty bottoms, waiting for prey to pass within striking distance. What makes them interesting to target is their responsiveness to technique. Flounder prefer live baits and small artificials worked slowly along the bottom, giving anglers time to connect with bites.
California flounder, despite its name, shows up regularly in Atlantic waters during warmer months. Southern flounder, the more traditional East Coast species, becomes more prevalent as summer progresses. Both species have excellent table quality, making them targets for anglers interested in fresh catch. They're not particularly aggressive fighters, but the challenge lies in detecting the subtle bite and maintaining bottom contact throughout the drift.
The habitat preference for both species means you're fishing fairly close to structure - drop-offs, channel edges, and bottom transitions where forage concentrates. These aren't open-water fish, so a charter guide's ability to read the bottom and identify productive zones directly impacts success. Captain Weigel's expertise in locating and working these areas shows in the results - two quality flounder in a single outing represents a successful day for most anglers targeting these species.
Flounder fishing also teaches patience. These fish don't chase - they hunt. Getting the bait in front of them and keeping it there long enough for them to make a decision is the real skill. Watching your line for that characteristic tap-tap sensation rather than an aggressive strike becomes second nature after a day of flounder fishing. It's a different pace than chasing pelagics or reef fish, and many anglers appreciate the technical challenge it presents.
Fishing in New York City: California Flounder and Southern Flounder
California Flounder Overview
Welcome to the world of the California Flounder (Paralichthys californicus), a fascinating member of the Paralichthyidae family within the order Pleuronectiformes. This unusual flatfish is one of Southern California's most intriguing bottom dwellers, known for its distinctive small head, formidable teeth, and remarkable ability to vanish into the sandy seafloor. What makes the California Flounder particularly special is that it breaks the mold of typical flatfish behavior—roughly half the population is right-eyed rather than left-eyed, making it genuinely atypical among its cousins. Whether you're an angler exploring the waters off Southern California or a curious seafood enthusiast, this species offers both challenge and culinary reward.
California Flounder Habitat and Distribution
The California Flounder thrives along the Pacific coast, ranging from Magdalena Bay in Baja California, Mexico, all the way north to the Quillayute River in British Columbia. You'll also find populations in the upper Gulf of California. The heart of their activity, however, centers around Southern California and the San Francisco Bay area, where they prefer sandy and muddy sediments on the ocean floor. These fish are demersal by nature, meaning they spend most of their adult lives hugging the bottom in inshore and nearshore waters, typically found between 100 and 330 feet of water. They congregate in bays and estuaries for spawning and juveniles settle in nurseries before eventually migrating toward the open coast as they mature. Some adventurous individuals venture near the surf zone, but most remain content in deeper, calmer waters.
California Flounder Size and Weight
California Flounder typically range from 54 to 60 inches in length, with weights generally between 6 and 30 pounds. However, specimens have been documented reaching at least 60 inches and weighing up to 72 pounds—truly impressive catches for dedicated anglers. These fish can live remarkably long lives, with some individuals reaching 30 years of age. Their oval-shaped body is noticeably more compact than the Pacific Halibut, which they're often mistaken for, and their dorsal and anal fins sport a more curved appearance compared to the more angular fins of their larger cousins. The eyed side typically displays greenish-brown or greyish coloring speckled with patterns, while the blind side is pale white or cream colored.
California Flounder Diet and Behavior
Though the California Flounder spends most of its time resting motionless on the seafloor, it's far from a passive feeder. When hunger calls, this fish becomes an active predator, using its exceptional camouflage and sharp teeth to ambush unsuspecting prey. It readily chases down meals, sometimes rising toward the surface in pursuit of food—behavior that occasionally brings it to the attention of observant anglers. The diet consists primarily of squids, sardines, and anchovies, though it will take other small fish species. Their sharp teeth and powerful bite are nothing to trifle with; anglers are strongly advised to handle these fish with care and respect. The California Flounder's color-changing abilities are genuinely impressive, allowing it to match the exact shade of the surrounding seafloor within minutes, making it nearly invisible to both prey and predators alike.
California Flounder Spawning and Seasonal Activity
The California Flounder exhibits interesting lifecycle patterns that influence angling success. Juveniles begin life as pelagic swimmers with eyes on both sides of their heads. As they mature over their first year, their eyes migrate to one side, and they begin their descent toward the bottom. Males typically reach maturity around 2 to 3 years and make their way toward the open coast, while females grow significantly larger before undertaking their coastal migration. Late spring marks the spawning period, making this season particularly productive for anglers targeting California Flounder. While the species isn't highly migratory, these seasonal movements create predictable hotspots and windows of opportunity that experienced anglers know well. Year-round availability means you can pursue this species almost any time, but timing your effort around the spawn dramatically increases your odds of success.
California Flounder Techniques for Observation and Capture
Flounder Gigging: One of the most effective and exciting methods for targeting California Flounder is night-time gigging from shallow-draft flats boats. Anglers deploy LED lights aimed at the bottom, which prevents the flounder from changing colors and blending into the seafloor. This technique makes the fish highly visible and vulnerable. Using a gig with multiple prongs, you strike quickly once a target is spotted. This method is especially popular in bays and shallow nearshore areas and requires stealth, patience, and good lighting equipment.
Drift Fishing with Light Tackle: For a more traditional approach, drift fishing over sandy bottoms with light tackle yields excellent results. Cast live bait—bull minnows, live squid, sardines, Pacific mackerel, mullet, pinfish, spots, croakers, or shrimp—and allow your line to drift with the current. A trap hook setup is recommended because California Flounder often mouth bait rather than fully committing to strikes. If you hook one, expect a determined but not particularly acrobatic fight. Around Southern California's coastal bays and near-shore drop-offs, this technique produces consistent catches from spring through early fall.
Artificial Lures: While live bait outperforms artificials significantly, bouncing small plastic grubs on jig heads along the bottom can produce moderate success for anglers willing to cover water. This technique works best during active feeding periods and requires patience and a sensitive touch to detect strikes.
California Flounder Culinary and Utilization Notes
The California Flounder earns top marks at the dinner table. When served raw, it boasts a clean, buttery flavor and tender texture that sushi enthusiasts appreciate. For cooked preparations, the flesh is remarkably forgiving, readily absorbing complementary flavors from sauces, herbs, and cooking methods. The key to success is a light hand—overcooking toughens the meat quickly, so brief cooking methods like pan-searing, poaching, or light baking work best. A single serving of California Flounder provides approximately 30 percent of an adult's recommended daily protein intake and delivers excellent sources of omega-3 fatty acids, vitamins B-6 and B-12, and potassium. The skin shrinks only moderately during cooking, making it ideal for filleting and pan-frying without distortion. For health-conscious diners and culinary adventurers alike, this species represents a sustainable, nutritious, and delicious choice.
California Flounder Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What is the best bait for catching California Flounder?
A: Live bait significantly outperforms artificial lures for this species. Bull minnows, live squid, sardines, Pacific mackerel, mullet, pinfish, spots, croakers, and shrimp are all effective. Use a trap hook setup to maximize hooking opportunities, as California Flounder often mouth bait before fully committing to a strike.
Q: Where can I find California Flounder near Southern California?
A: The best populations occur in bays and estuaries from San Francisco southward along the California coast. Look for sandy or muddy bottoms in depths of 100 to 330 feet. Specific hotspots include San Diego Bay, Huntington Harbor, Newport Harbor, and various nearshore areas along the Orange County and Los Angeles coasts.
Q: Is California Flounder good to eat?
A: Absolutely! California Flounder is considered excellent for the table. It features buttery, clean-tasting flesh that readily absorbs flavors. Cook it quickly with a light touch to preserve tenderness, and you'll enjoy a highly nutritious meal rich in protein, omega-3s, and B vitamins.
Q: When is the best time to catch California Flounder?
A: While available year-round, late spring during the spawning season offers the most productive fishing. Summer and early fall also provide excellent opportunities. Night-time gigging is effective year-round, particularly in shallow bays.
Q: How do I handle California Flounder safely?
A: Exercise extreme caution with the sharp teeth—these fish can bite hard and cause injury. Use a wet glove or cloth to grip them, avoid placing fingers near the mouth, and consider using a fish gripper designed for flatfish.
Q: Are California Flounder and Pacific Halibut the same fish?
A: No. California Flounder is smaller with a more oval body and more curved fins compared to the Pacific Halibut's larger, more angular frame. Additionally, roughly half of California Flounder populations are right-eyed, which is atypical for flatfish—a trait that distinguishes them from Pacific Halibut.
Southern Flounder Overview
The Southern Flounder (Paralichthys lethostigma) is a fascinating member of the Paralichthyidae family within the order Pleuronectiformes. What makes this flatfish truly remarkable is its distinctive asymmetrical eye placement—both eyes positioned on the left side of its head—and its remarkable ability to camouflage itself against sandy and muddy bottoms. These bottom-dwelling ambush predators are native to coastal waters across the Atlantic seaboard and Gulf of Mexico, making them a favorite target for both recreational and commercial anglers. Unlike their close cousin the Summer Flounder, Southern Flounders display numerous light and dark blotches rather than the oscillating spot patterns found on other flounder species. Whether you're casting lines near coastal channels or exploring estuaries, encountering this skilled predator is a genuine thrill that keeps anglers coming back season after season.
Southern Flounder Habitat and Distribution
Southern Flounders thrive in shallow coastal marine environments spanning from the Atlantic seaboard down through the Gulf of Mexico. You'll find them inhabiting sandy, rocky, or muddy bottoms in bays, rivers, lakes, estuaries, and inshore channels where they can easily ambush unsuspecting prey. These fish prefer staying in water shallow enough to maintain their bottom-dwelling lifestyle, which makes them accessible to shore-based and small boat anglers alike. During winter months, most adult specimens migrate offshore to deeper, warmer waters, so timing your fishing trips accordingly can significantly impact your success rates. The species thrives in areas with strong tidal currents and rich prey populations, making river mouths and coastal channels particularly productive fishing zones.
Southern Flounder Size and Weight
Southern Flounders typically range from 12 to 18 inches in length, with exceptional specimens stretching up to 33 inches or more. The average catch weighs around 1 to 4 pounds, which makes for excellent table fare and enjoyable sport on light-to-medium tackle. However, the all-tackle weight record stands at an impressive 20 pounds 9 ounces, proving that genuine trophy-sized flounders do exist for patient and skilled anglers willing to pursue them. Size varies considerably depending on habitat quality, water temperature, and food availability, with offshore populations generally producing larger specimens than their inshore cousins.
Southern Flounder Diet and Behavior
These masterful hunters are ambush predators that spend much of their day buried beneath sand or mud on the seafloor, waiting for unsuspecting prey to swim overhead. Their primary diet consists of worms, shrimp, blue crabs, and smaller fish species including anchovies, menhaden, and mullets. What's truly impressive is their ability to change color and pattern to perfectly match their surrounding substrate, effectively becoming invisible to both prey and predators. This chameleon-like adaptation is one of nature's most effective hunting strategies. Southern Flounders exhibit anguilliform swimming patterns, using their bodies and caudal fin to move gracefully through water despite their flattened body shape. Behaviorally, they're most active during tidal movements when increased water flow brings more food opportunities within striking distance.
Southern Flounder Spawning and Seasonal Activity
Female Southern Flounders demonstrate remarkable reproductive capacity, capable of releasing up to 9,000 eggs during a single spawning event. Spawning typically occurs during late fall and winter months, with larvae drifting into estuaries and shallow bays as nursery grounds throughout spring and early summer. Juvenile flounders grow rapidly in these nutrient-rich nurseries before gradually moving to deeper offshore waters as they mature. Males exhibit notably shorter lifespans compared to females, typically living only three years maximum, while females can reach considerably older ages. This pronounced sexual dimorphism in lifespan makes protecting breeding populations especially important for long-term fishery sustainability.
Southern Flounder Techniques for Observation or Capture
Still Fishing and Drift Fishing: The most effective method involves still fishing or drift fishing directly over known flounder habitat on sandy or muddy bottoms. Position your boat in channels or along drop-offs where these fish congregate. Use a single-hooked slip lead or free-line rig with heads ranging from 1/4 to 3/8 inches. Light-to-medium rod and reel combinations spooled with 10-pound test line work perfectly. Cast your rig uptide and maintain bottom contact, feeling for the characteristic tap-tap-tap of a feeding flounder.
Live Bait Presentation: Bull minnows, mullets, and live shrimp represent the gold standard baits for Southern Flounders. Present these offerings on the bottom where flounders hunt, allowing natural movement to trigger strikes. Around coastal areas like the Louisiana bayous or North Carolina sounds, fresh live shrimp often outperforms all other baits, particularly during peak tidal movements.
Fly Fishing: For a more engaging challenge, try fly fishing with medium-weight lines and small streamer patterns that mimic baitfish. Cast along channel edges and drop-offs, then execute slow, pulsing retrieves near the bottom. This technique works particularly well in shallower estuarine waters where sight-casting is possible.
Southern Flounder Culinary and Utilization Notes
Southern Flounder ranks among the finest eating flatfish available to anglers, featuring delicate, mild white meat with excellent flavor and tender texture. The meat cooks beautifully whether pan-seared, baked, or deep-fried, making it a favorite at both family dinners and upscale restaurants. A single 2-3 pound flounder provides a satisfying meal for two people, while larger specimens offer enough fillets for family gatherings. The high-quality protein, low fat content, and absence of strong fishy flavors make this species appealing even to seafood skeptics. From a sustainability perspective, recreational harvest at reasonable levels remains sustainable in most regions, though always check local regulations and size limits before keeping your catch.
Southern Flounder Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What is the best bait for catching Southern Flounder?
A: Live bull minnows, mullets, and shrimp consistently outperform artificial offerings. Fresh live shrimp typically produces the highest success rates, particularly during moving tide periods when flounders actively feed. The key is presenting your bait directly on the bottom where these ambush predators hunt.
Q: How do I distinguish a Southern Flounder from a Summer Flounder?
A: The most reliable distinguishing feature is the spot pattern on the dark side. Southern Flounders display numerous light and dark blotches and irregular spots, while Summer Flounders exhibit more uniform, oscillating spot patterns. Additionally, Southern Flounders typically have less developed pectoral fins compared to their cousins.
Q: When is the best time to catch Southern Flounder?
A: Spring through early fall offers excellent opportunities as fish remain in shallower inshore waters. Winter months see most flounders migrating offshore to deeper refuge, making them harder to access from shore. Tidal movements create peak feeding windows, so fish moving tides whenever possible for maximum productivity.
Q: Are Southern Flounders good to eat?
A: Absolutely—they rank among the finest-tasting flatfish available. The delicate white meat offers mild flavor and tender texture, cooking beautifully through multiple preparation methods. A 2-3 pound flounder provides an excellent meal, while larger specimens offer abundant fillets for family dining.
Q: What fishing techniques work best for Southern Flounder?
A: Still fishing and drift fishing over bottom habitat produce the most consistent results. Position your boat in channels or along defined drop-offs, maintaining bottom contact with your rig. Light-to-medium tackle spooled with 10-pound test line provides excellent sensitivity for detecting the subtle takes these bottom feeders produce.
Q: Can I sight-cast to Southern Flounder in shallow water?
A: Yes, in clear shallow estuaries and bays you can occasionally spot feeding flounders and cast to them directly. However, their excellent camouflage makes spotting them challenging. Fly fishing with streamers works well in these situations, though traditional bottom-fishing techniques remain more consistently productive.
